AAdvantage Lawsuit Claims American Airlines Wrongfully Terminated Members’ Accounts, Wiped Out Reward Miles
Nachison et al. v. American Airlines, Inc.
Filed: January 29, 2024 ◆§ 5:24-cv-00530
A class action alleges American Airlines has wrongfully terminated the accounts of AAdvantage members and seized their accrued airline miles without cause.
A proposed class action alleges American Airlines has wrongfully terminated the accounts of certain AAdvantage program members and seized their accrued airline mile benefits without cause.
Was your AAdvantage account closed by American Airlines after you signed up for a Citibank credit card promotion that offered bonus miles? Let us know here.
The 28-page lawsuit was filed by two California consumers who claim the airline improperly closed their frequent flyer reward program accounts, resulting in the combined loss of more than one million validly earned miles and the cancelation of upcoming flights booked with miles.
The proposed class action lawsuit explains that AAdvantage members can earn miles—which can be redeemed when purchasing flights or for flight upgrades, car rentals and more—by using credit cards issued by the airline’s co-branding partners, including Citibank and Barclays. Members can rack up miles through enrollment bonuses when they open a Citi-AAdvantage or Barclays-AAdvantage credit card and when using their card to make everyday purchases, the case shares.
Want to stay in the loop on class actions that matter to you? Sign up for ClassAction.org’s free weekly newsletter here.
As the complaint tells it, many consumers take advantage of these promotions and open multiple American Airlines-branded credit cards because doing so does not violate any restrictions in the AAdvantage program’s contract terms. In fact, the filing argues that the airline even encourages customers to enroll in and use multiple credit card accounts by sending credit card applications before and after an accountholder has received their card.
As such, American Airlines has no basis for shutting down members’ AAdvantage accounts, the lawsuit contends.
What’s more, the defendant does not adequately disclose to AAdvantage members why their accounts have been terminated, the suit claims. Per the case, when the airline shut down the plaintiffs’ accounts, the consumers were informed via email that the termination stemmed from alleged violations of the “General AAdvantage Program Conditions” and the accrual of miles and benefits through “fraud, misrepresentation and/or abuse of the AAdvantage Program.”
The plaintiffs—who, like many consumers, earned miles by enrolling in and using multiple American Airlines-branded credit cards—say they did not engage in any fraud when applying for the credit cards, and complied with all requirements and restrictions associated with opening several accounts.
“[American Airlines’] decision to terminate AAdvantage accounts entirely was improper and denied AAdvantage members the benefits they had accrued through previous purchases,” the complaint charges. “It is unclear precisely why [American Airlines] decided to terminate AAdvantage accounts—but it is clear that doing so was improper.”
The filing alleges that American Airlines has used this as an opportunity to “steal” AAdvantage members’ accrued bonus miles, all of which are seized upon an account’s closure, regardless of how they were earned.
“Even if [American Airlines] believed that AAdvantage account holders had engaged in fraud or improper conduct in taking advantage of the Citi-AAdvantage credit card or Barclays-AAdvantage credit card promotions (even if while acting in compliance with the promotions’ terms and restrictions), [the airline] could have simply seized those miles that were earned specifically based on enrollment through those promotions. But [American Airlines] did not do so. Instead, it saw this as an opportunity to seize customers’ entire accounts and all of their miles, and to close their existing accounts completely. Doing so ensured that [American Airlines] would no longer be required to provide the monetary benefits to these account holders through trading in bonus miles for tickets, hotel promotions, or flight seating upgrades, etc.—all of which held monetary value that [the defendant] would be responsible for.”
The lawsuit looks to represent anyone whose AAdvantage membership was terminated by American Airlines based on allegations of fraud related to the member’s application for, opening of or use of a Citi-AAdvantage or Barclays-AAdvantage credit card.
Was your AAdvantage account closed by American Airlines after you signed up for a Citibank credit card promotion that offered bonus miles? Let us know here.
Hair Relaxer Lawsuits
Women who developed ovarian or uterine cancer after using hair relaxers such as Dark & Lovely and Motions may now have an opportunity to take legal action.
Read more here: Hair Relaxer Cancer Lawsuits
How Do I Join a Class Action Lawsuit?
Did you know there's usually nothing you need to do to join, sign up for, or add your name to new class action lawsuits when they're initially filed?
Read more here: How Do I Join a Class Action Lawsuit?
Stay Current
Sign Up For
Our Newsletter
New cases and investigations, settlement deadlines, and news straight to your inbox.
Before commenting, please review our comment policy.